Our Option

Our Option. The Insurance Clause Most Texans Have Never Heard of

Your home insurance policy gives your carrier a powerful alternative to writing you a check. Here’s what it means, when they’ll use it, and how to protect yourself if you’d rather call the shots yourself.

You file a homeowner’s claim. You’re already mentally picturing the payout hitting your bank account, a check you can hand to your cousin’s remodeling crew, or the contractor you’ve used for years. But buried in the fine print of nearly every Texas homeowner’s insurance policy is a clause that can change that picture entirely. It’s called Our Option, and understanding it could save you a serious headache when you need your coverage most.

What exactly is “Our Option”?

“Our Option” is a policy provision that gives your insurance carrier the right to repair or replace the damaged property instead of paying you a cash settlement. Rather than cutting you a check and stepping back, the insurer steps forward as project manager, hiring the contractors and overseeing the work themselves.

The policy language

In plain terms, the clause typically reads something like: “We may repair or replace any part of the damaged property with equivalent material and workmanship at our option.” That “at our option” is doing a lot of work.

Carriers don’t invoke this clause on every claim. But when they do, it changes the entire dynamic of the claim process, and it pays to know what you’re agreeing to.

When will a carrier actually use it?

Insurers tend to reach for Our Option in a few specific situations:

  • High-dollar claims: where the insurer can negotiate contractor rates they couldn’t get if they simply handed you a check
  • Disputes over scope: if you and the adjuster can’t agree on what needs to be replaced versus repaired, exercising Our Option lets the carrier control the outcome
  • Fraud concerns: when the carrier has questions about the claimed damages, managing the repair directly lets them verify what actually gets fixed
  • Catastrophe events: (hailstorms, freezes, hurricanes), where managing thousands of claims efficiently makes direct repair programs attractive
  • When cash settlements would trigger large mortgage company involvement:  which brings us to one of the biggest hidden benefits of this provision

The benefits — why this can actually work in your favor

For many homeowners, Our Option isn’t a trap. It can significantly streamline your claim. Here’s why:

Advantages
  • No back-and-forth with your mortgage company
  • The insurer acts as your general contractor
  • Work is guaranteed, and the carrier stands behind it
  • No juggling subcontractors or payments
  • Faster resolution on complex claims
  • Disputes over scope fall on the carrier
Trade-offs
  • You don’t choose your contractor
  • Less flexibility on upgrades or changes
  • May conflict with trusted relationships
  • Can’t use a family member’s business
  • Carrier controls materials and timeline
  • Less negotiating room on the final result
The mortgage company headache — solved

When a claim check is made out jointly to you and your mortgage lender, you’re at their mercy. Lenders can hold funds in escrow, require inspections at each draw, and delay the process for weeks or months. When the carrier exercises Our Option, that check often never exists, so the mortgage company never enters the picture. The work gets done, and the claim closes without you serving as an intermediary.

Perhaps the biggest comfort is that when a carrier acts as the general contractor, they are responsible for the quality of the work. If the repair fails or something was done wrong, you have a clear path back to your insurer, not to a contractor who has moved on to the next job. That workmanship guarantee is a meaningful protection.

When you might not want the carrier to exercise it

Our Option isn’t always the right answer. There are real, legitimate reasons you may want to control the repair process yourself:

  • You have a contractor you trust deeply —maybe someone who has worked on your home for years and knows its quirks
  • A family member is in the trades — a son-in-law who is a licensed roofer, a sibling who runs a restoration company. A cash settlement means you can hire them; Our Option means you can’t
  • You want to use the claim as an opportunity to upgrade — paying the difference for premium materials is easier when you’re managing the project
  • You have concerns about the carrier’s preferred contractor network — not all managed repair programs are equal
  • The damage is in a specialized area — historic homes, custom finishes, or unusual construction, where a generic crew may not be the right fit

None of these reasons makes you a difficult policyholder. They make you an informed one.

How to opt out before and after a claim

The good news: Our Option is a right the carrier may exercise, not one they must. And in many cases, you have options of your own.

1. Read your policy before you ever have a claim. Locate the Our Option provision. It’s usually in the “Loss Settlement” or “Conditions” section. Understand what it says, and whether there are any existing limitations on when it can be invoked.

2. At the time of the claim, make your preference known early. Contact your adjuster or agent immediately and state clearly, ideally in writing (an email will suffice), that you want to settle the claim with a cash payment and manage the repairs yourself. Many carriers will honor this without a fight, especially on smaller or straightforward claims.

3. If the carrier insists on exercising Our Option, get everything in writing. Ask for the scope of work, the contractor’s license and insurance information, the timeline, and the workmanship warranty terms before any work begins. You are entitled to this information.

4. Know your rights under the Texas Prompt Payment Act. If there’s a dispute about how your claim is being settled, including the method of settlement, the Texas Department of Insurance has a complaint process, and a licensed public adjuster or policyholder attorney can help you navigate it.

One important nuance

Even when a carrier exercises Our Option, they typically cannot force you to accept substandard work. If the repairs don’t restore your property to its pre-loss condition using materials of like kind and quality, you have grounds to push back and potentially to demand a cash settlement for the shortfall. Document everything throughout the process.

The bottom line

Our Option is one of those policy provisions that sounds one-sided at first, and in some situations, it is. But it also represents a genuine benefit for homeowners who don’t want the hassle of managing a complex claim, dealing with a lender holding their money, or tracking down subcontractors.

The key is knowing it’s there before you need it. Talk to your independent agent about how your current policy handles this clause, under what circumstances your carrier is likely to invoke it, and whether there are options to customize your coverage so it works the way you want it to when the storm comes.

Have questions about your current homeowners policy and how Our Option might apply to your situation? Your independent agent is the best place to start — before you’re standing in a flooded living room trying to figure it out on the fly.

 

Learn More About Us